Rethinking Mosque Spaces in Shaping British Muslim Identity

Rethinking Mosque Spaces in Shaping British Muslim Identity

Mosque architecture in the UK presents a complex challenge, combining both aesthetic and socio-cultural dimensions. Historically, many mosques have been established in repurposed residential or commercial structures, resulting in a lack of architectural coherence, design ingenuity and optimal facilities. This issue is further compounded by the necessity to harmonise traditional Islamic architectural elements with the local British architectural style.

Young British Muslims have been active in efforts to interrogate the existing norms within the traditional mosque landscape, especially regarding how “mosque politics” has complicated their construction of identity and community. Two prominent themes emerged around “mosque politics”: design and diversity. The last was particularly pertinent and timely. For example, plans for the opening of a women-led mosque in Bradford in 2015 reinforced the exclusionary nature of mainstream mosques.

My discussions with young British Muslims underlined the argument in Vincent Biondo’s 2006 article The Architecture of Mosques in the US and Britain that traditional mosque architecture in Western contexts creates confused identities for Muslims. Coupled with the ethnocentricity of British mosques, this has often complicated the desire for young British Muslims to integrate their faith and national identities. This raises an important question: could a cohesive British Muslim identity be formed if the mosque fulfils its original and historic role as an open communal space?

Through my research, I explored the socio-spatial role of mosques in shaping a cohesive British Muslim identity, with a particular focus on design and diversity. “Socio-spatial” refers to how social relations shape and are shaped by spatial environments. This term is helpful in illustrating the role of the mosque as both a religious and social space, using Prophet Muhammad’s mosque in Medina as an example. As part of my Fellowship, I travelled to Canada, South Africa and the United States to research best practice in mosque design and functionality amongst minority Muslim communities, interviewing Muslim stakeholders and conducting over 30 individual meetings and large focus groups to develop the key themes in my research.

"This raises an important question: could a cohesive British Muslim identity be formed if the mosque fulfils its original and historic role as an open communal space?"

I am cautious to offer recommendations which could be seen as prescriptive for several reasons. First, there are no strict religious rules in mosque design, allowing Muslim communities to create places of worship which align with their needs. It would be unwise, therefore, to determine what is acceptable as this depends on the requirements of each local community. Furthermore, such flexibility in mosque design is an asset, and one which should be promoted.

Second, I am aware of grassroots initiatives, led and facilitated by Muslim organisations in the UK, working to change the current paradigm in mosque design and functionality. For example, the Muslim Council of Britain (MCB), the largest and most diverse representative body for the British Muslim community in the UK, offers training around good governance in this area. Consequently, it seems sensible to let such initiatives run their course.

Third, it would be impossible to recreate the current mosque landscape in the UK to better express modern architectural styles. Despite their architectural shortcomings, existing mosques in the UK were built to reflect a certain historical context. They are a testament to a bygone era and an impetus to build new ones differently in the future – the recently built Cambridge Central Mosque in Cambridge is a salient example.

With that in mind, my research provides three practical recommendations that could help foster a cohesive faith and national identity amongst young British Muslims, especially in relation to the mosque’s role:

  1. The representation of young British Muslims from diverse backgrounds to mosque committees, boards or other governing structures.
  2. Where mosques are unable for practical reasons to support them within their existing structures, the development of supplementary “third spaces” designed for young and diverse British Muslims to fulfil their social, cultural and spiritual needs.
  3. Training and guidance for existing mosque boards and committees around best practice on mosque design, particularly in respect of (a) creating spaces for women and other marginalised groups and (b) focusing funding efforts for these objectives.

I sincerely hope that mosque leaders and wider stakeholders will be encouraged to empower the younger generation to create mosques that reflect and reinforce a 21st-century Western context.

Disclaimer

The views and opinions expressed by any Fellow are those of the Fellow and not of the Churchill Fellowship or its partners, which have no responsibility or liability for any part of them.

Related

Blogs & conversations

Adultifying Black Girls

Through my Churchill Fellowship, I explored how Black girls are adultified in state care – from their relationships with parents to social work practices and transitions to independent living. Travelling to the USA and Canada, I engaged with researchers and practitioners, uncovering how adultification affects Black girls and identifying potential solutions. My findings highlight the need to move beyond tick-box approaches in social work and recognise the strengths Black girls develop despite these challenges. I’m now sharing these insights through CPD sessions, campaigns, and my ongoing PhD, with the hope of driving meaningful change for children affected.

By Sylvia Ikomi,

Amy Davies
Blogs & conversations

Improving the housing experience for older LGBTQ+ people

I’d known about the Churchill Fellowship for years, but my journey began while watching Drag Race Spain last year, where I learned about Fundación 26 de Diciembre, an organisation supporting older LGBTQ+ people in Madrid. This inspired me to apply for a Fellowship, and I was awarded funding to visit LGBTQ+ housing and care projects in Spain, France, Germany, and study online with groups in Sweden and the USA. I’m excited to bring back what I learn to improve housing and care experiences for older LGBTQ+ people here in the UK.

By Amy Davies,

Blogs & conversations

In Conversation with: Carole Phillips – ongoing influence of a Fellowship

We spoke to Churchill Fellow Carole Phillips about her journey since receiving a Fellowship ten years ago. As an anti-bullying advocate, Carole shares how her experiences have shaped her work in promoting children's wellbeing. Her Fellowship took her to the USA to study the Olweus Bullying Prevention Programme, inspiring her to develop a finalist anti-bullying programme in Wales’s Police Community Awards. Now with Jigsaw Education Group, she supports schools in implementing PSHE content while continuing her advocacy for children affected by bullying.

By Carole Phillips,

Blogs & conversations

In conversation with: Mark Brookes – shining a spotlight on disability hate crime

We spoke to Churchill Fellow Dr Mark Brookes, advocacy lead at Dimensions, who will soon travel to the USA for his Fellowship, where he will share his insights on hate crime reporting and its connection to learning disabilities. With over 20 years of advocacy experience, Mark emphasises the challenges individuals with learning disabilities face when reporting hate crimes and highlights the significant achievements his work has led to, as well as his hopes for improving hate crime reporting and outcomes for disabled individuals in the UK.

By Mark Brookes,

Newsletter Sign Up